Copyright filters haven't killed Mininova just yet
07/09 2009 | 03:57 PM
Posted by: Janko Roettgers
All eyes have been on the Pirate Bay in recent weeks, but the Swedish pirates aren't the only ones forced to radical changes due to increased pressure of rights holders. The Dutch torrent site Mininova.org has been defending itself in court since early June, with a verdict due at the end of August.
Mininova has started to take a more proactive approach against infringement, filtering out infringing torrents much like Youtube is filtering its uploads. The Mininova staff described these filters this way:
"(L)ikely infringing video files referred to by torrents are checked by a third party content recognition system. If the system finds that the file corresponds to unauthorized content, we remove and block the torrent that refers to this file on Mininova."
The announcement was met with a lot of skepticism from Mininova's users, with many users denouncing it as suicde. Well, guess what: It's two months later, and Mininova is still very much alive. The site clocked almost 45 million uniques and over 628 million page views last month. However, there are some early signs for users abandoning the site because of the filters.

Most websites have pretty heavy seasonal ups and downs. That's traditionally also been true for file sharing communities and services, which usually tend to get much less traffic during the summer months. Kids that travel don't download that much. You can see that Mininova had some of those seasonal ups and downs earlier this year as well.
However, Mininova had a clear dip in page views in June. Page views were down by almost 14 percent month-to-month. Visits declined only by ten percent, which seems to be an indicator for users spending less time and clicking on less links on the site.
The next few months could be make or break for Mininova. Back to school will be a good indicator on whether users are coming back to the site or switch to torrent sites without filters, and any court decision that would force Mininova to even slightly stricter controls could spell trouble for the site.
Mininova has started to take a more proactive approach against infringement, filtering out infringing torrents much like Youtube is filtering its uploads. The Mininova staff described these filters this way:
"(L)ikely infringing video files referred to by torrents are checked by a third party content recognition system. If the system finds that the file corresponds to unauthorized content, we remove and block the torrent that refers to this file on Mininova."
The announcement was met with a lot of skepticism from Mininova's users, with many users denouncing it as suicde. Well, guess what: It's two months later, and Mininova is still very much alive. The site clocked almost 45 million uniques and over 628 million page views last month. However, there are some early signs for users abandoning the site because of the filters.
Most websites have pretty heavy seasonal ups and downs. That's traditionally also been true for file sharing communities and services, which usually tend to get much less traffic during the summer months. Kids that travel don't download that much. You can see that Mininova had some of those seasonal ups and downs earlier this year as well.
However, Mininova had a clear dip in page views in June. Page views were down by almost 14 percent month-to-month. Visits declined only by ten percent, which seems to be an indicator for users spending less time and clicking on less links on the site.
The next few months could be make or break for Mininova. Back to school will be a good indicator on whether users are coming back to the site or switch to torrent sites without filters, and any court decision that would force Mininova to even slightly stricter controls could spell trouble for the site.


steve wrote:
1. the mass majority dont even know their filtering they never bother using or reading news anywhere they just come to the site hit a link it downloads they get the content in the end.
until that stops happening people will continue to use it
2. 90% of the trackers in the torrents is piratebay when they go legal to this new DRM pay shop that tracker address for the announce will be useless nothing will download then all the users will start to search the problem out in google then suddenly find piratebay has been sold, and then further find out mininova started filtering they will then go ah... explains for months now why half my torrents didn't work..
i bet you a penny to a pound if mininova put the copyright filters on their front page as in plain view instead of hiding away the facts from the users or making it so people have to read news story's on 3rd party sites i bet their service would tank in 2 days.
This piratebay sellout will be the best thing for public awareness and i cannot wait, same if mininova shut down its the best thing for the world.
it would force people to finally search for p2p news in some or other then find all these news websites that promote new sites people are using or newer technology, then and only then would people come to learn or know about p2p news because at present time a good % of the world doesn't even know news and info sites like these exists